A Fresh Look at an 'Inevitable' War

March 6, 2008

A Fresh Look at an 'Inevitable' War

Human Smoke by Nicholson Baker is a monumental work of research about the causes and the avoidability of the Second World War--in its short-take composition, it's structurally reminiscent of Clive James' recent compendium Cultural Amnesia. Many of the heroic myths about Winston Churchill suffer badly at Baker's (and these selected historical records') hands, as this always-surprising author builds a case for pacifism as a plausible and possible alternative to what most historians claim was an inevitable war.

TAGS:

Comments

Odile's picture

Human Smoke is getting a lot

Human Smoke is getting a lot of attention. A particularly interesting and balanced review of the book is Louis Menand's in the New Yorker . But if you are interested in the controversy that it has generated read Richard Cohen's opinion in the Washington Post.